HOW DOES CULTURE SHAPES CREATIVITY?

Great artists and innovators have always captivated human curiosity with their brilliant ideas.  The question of how they develop these concepts has intrigued us for ages.  A quick Google search for “creative process” will lead you down a rabbit hole of clickbait offering easy-to-follow tips for a more creative life. However, this isn’t the whole story.  Creativity arises from a complex, non-linear, and multifaceted set of processes that transcend individual capacity. It’s not just about thinking; it’s also about the environment in which we live and learn – our culture.

Before delving into culture, let’s define it. Given its many meanings, this article focuses on shared patterns of behaviour, interactions, and cognitive constructs acquired through socialisation. (This definition is from the Centre for Advanced Research on Language Acquisition.) Culture is the development of group identity shaped by distinctive social patterns within a community, society, or region.

Culture influences far beyond our diet and clothing choices. It shapes our beliefs (including religious and superstitious beliefs), our social norms, and, most importantly, our thinking.  This is crucial because, as most of us think using words, we’re inherently connected to countless meanings and symbols embedded in our mother tongue.  Simply by thinking, we’re constantly shaping our perception of the world, much like our language becomes the first lens through which we understand reality.

As human beings, we limit our understanding of reality to our worldview.  This combination of our unique experiences, background, interests, languages, and the society we inhabit shapes our perceptions. These systems not only help us navigate the complexities of perception but also provide the framework for interpreting the world.

Our creative thinking is also shaped by culture.  Creativity arises from processes that link symbols, images, assumptions and guidelines – acquired through individual and contextual experiences.  This means we’re always somewhat trapped within our cultural context.

Culture influences how we process information and defines what we mean by creativity.  The question arises: are the creative processes across cultures completely distinct?

Numerous studies show that societies shape various aspects of creative expression.  Researchers from diverse backgrounds agree that artists from different cultures prioritise different aspects of the creative process, impacting their work.

Let’s focus on some key differences between Western and Eastern cultures that might influence creative processes.  Western cultures include European countries and those heavily influenced by its immigration, like the US.  Eastern cultures encompass the Indian subcontinent, China, Japan, Vietnam, North and South Korea. All information here comes from academic sources mentioned at the end.

Perceptions of originality and uniqueness vary widely across societies. This affects how audiences adopt innovation and influences an artist’s path.  Substantial evidence suggests that Western and individualistic cultures value novel solutions, while Eastern and collectivist cultures prioritise useful solutions. This aligns with Western beliefs.

Systems based on individualism, freedom, and democracy respond more effectively to innovative models.  Conversely, a focus on usefulness reflects a strong reliance on the tradition of collective Eastern societies rooted in interdependence, cooperation and collectivity.

Another interesting point is the dominance of incremental patterns in Eastern creativity and radical patterns in Western creativity.  This means that Eastern cultures often view creativity as an ongoing process, adding new layers to an initial idea, whereas Western cultures generally see it as a linear journey toward a new goal, breaking existing systems to create something entirely new.

However, the world isn’t so black and white. We live in a global, hyper-connected context, incorporating elements from various regions into our culture.  Cultural intersections lead artists to incorporate new symbols and draw inspiration from the reappropriation of ideas, broadening their creative process.  This curiosity about the unknown, a natural trait of creative professionals, not only pushes the boundaries of thought but also connects artists with diverse audiences through shared cultural knowledge.

These are simplified perspectives.  We haven’t considered the pluralities and particularities of Latin, Middle Eastern, or African cultures, nor have we addressed post-demographic aspects such as religion, ethnicity, or ethical beliefs.  Furthermore, cultures are inherently fluid and constantly evolving.  Finally, individual minds are uniquely shaped.

References and personal experiences suggest that it’s difficult to identify a culture-traced pattern, even when considering factors such as identity, background, and field of work.  After all, creativity arises from a complex, nonlinear interplay of processes that exceed individual capacity.  Much remains to be explored and discussed, and it’s crucial to establish independent spaces for cultural and thought exchange. This exercise is the first step towards more empathetic artistic institutions.

Articles cited:

Xie G., Paik Y. (2019). Cultural differences in creativity and innovation: are Asian employees truly less creative than Western employees?

Rudowicz E. (2003). Creativity and culture: a two-way interaction

Kaufman J. C., Lan L. (2012). East-west cultural bias and creativity: we are alike and we are different.

Shen W. B., Yuan Y. (2015). Sociocultural basis underlying creative thinking.

Lubart T. I. (1999). “Creativity across cultures” in Creativity research handbook

Shao, Yong et al (2019). “How Does Culture Shape Creativity? A Mini-Review.”

Next
Next

Soft subjects: Is the educational system impeding creative ambition?