Does the greatest art come from talented strangers or from close friendships? Collaboration helps us go beyond the isolated genius and explore new creative paths. But under what conditions does collaboration flourish? Specifically, how does the existing relationship between artists influence the outcome? We examine whether the friction in diversity allows strangers, brought together intentionally, to create boundary-breaking art that challenges norms. Or, does greater value emerge when friends with shared understanding unify to shape their art, sparking movements? Studies touch on this, and history and anecdotes fill the gaps where research is inconclusive. A Stanford study found that working with friends is not ideal for success, arguing that friends may hesitate to critique one another when it counts, potentially harming the project. However, this is not the focus here. Instead, the Stanford conditions help us explore the benefits and risks of each collaboration style.
One variable is that the groups in the study included both friends and strangers, with results averaged from all participants. Looking at the letters of the Bloomsbury Group, we question whether strangers can hinder friendships from having open conversations. Vanessa Bell, an artist in the group, wrote to her husband that while they could candidly call each other prigs and adulterers in small, select circles, larger groups might not feel comfortable doing so, as members might not feel entirely on neutral ground.
The close friendships within Bloomsbury created a safe space for sharing and debating even controversial ideas. Contrary to the polite, supportive exchanges of the Stanford experiment, Virginia Woolf described Bloomsbury as ‘like nothing so much as the lions’ house at the zoo,’ full of animals that were “dangerous and suspicious but also full of fascination and mystery.’
Similarly, the Inklings of Oxford—C.S. Lewis, J.R.R. Tolkien, and others—shared a comparable dynamic. Lewis’s brother described their meetings as follows: “There was no mutual admiration society; praise for good work was unstinting, but criticism, even of less stellar efforts, was often brutally honest. Reading to the Inklings was a formidable challenge.”
Perhaps the trust developed through close friendships fosters honest conversations that help nurture and refine artworks for their improvement.
Friday, 8 May 2020
But when so many renowned figures emerge within only a few creative circles, we wonder whether their fame stems from the quality of their work or the strength of their connections. Standing Vanessa Bell next to her peer, Suzanne Duchamp, we observe that their work is of a comparable standard. However, while Duchamp’s network was limited to Dada artists, Bell’s greater fame likely resulted from her extensive networks that brought her art to prominent places.
Today, we still see echoes of elitism in the art world, implying that fame is more an illusion of creativity than a true indicator of talent. Cambridge Footlights has been criticised as a launchpad for clone comedians: white, male, middle or upper class. The work of Eric Idle, Stephen Fry, Hugh Laurie, Rowan Atkinson, and David Mitchell has achieved significant acclaim. But could a more diverse group have produced even better work?
Similarly, when group intimacy is high, does it stifle innovation? Where does diversity fit in when groups share similar mindsets? Intentional collaborations between talented strangers can offer opportunities for diverse artists to unite in striking contrast and unexpected harmonies. Ibraham Karma, Stylist and Senior Fashion Editor at Large for i-D, recently mused that the world might be a better place if creators focused solely on their own work without concern for others. He suggests that cross-pollination can sometimes kill ideas and dreams that deserve full exploration before they are combined in collaboration.
The physical distancing imposed by the coronavirus pandemic might have facilitated such collaborations. Wallpaper’s World View series enabled a diverse array of artists worldwide to participate in a joint art project. The results demonstrate the immense diversity within the artistic community, even when responding to the same stimuli.
Contrasting this perspective is Michal P Farrell’s socialist study on collaborative circles. He examined how shared social class and geography create the conditions conducive to flourishing artistic movements. He argues that the finest artwork is produced by groups whose aligned values foster mutual creativity. He defines a collaborative circle as ‘a group consisting of peers who share similar occupational goals and who, through prolonged dialogue and collaboration, negotiate a common vision that guides their work.’
The idea of longevity is intriguing here. Returning to the Stanford experiment, we note it was conducted over just a few weeks, recognising that results might vary over time. If sustained dialogue is crucial to the success of a collaborative circle, then do friends produce better work through continuous collaboration? Conversely, do strangers have an advantage in optimising tasks?
As we conclude, we understand that valuable art emerges from both deliberate and organic collaborations. But we also ask whether certain conditions can optimise each type.
If diversity encourages strangers to create engaging, unique art, then perhaps this collaboration is most effective over a short period with a clear, singular outcome. Conversely, the value of long-term friendships coming together to define entire artistic epochs is evident, giving rise to movements that transcend individual pieces. Perhaps this isn’t about determining whether one form of collaboration is superior, but about how we appreciate the outcomes. So, what truly makes great art?